Est. 1992

Made with love like we’re cooking for your mama!

Hands reaching for pizza and wings

Your go-to pizza shop for over 25 years.

Craving a NY-style slice, but can’t visit New York City? Let us feed you our delicious, handmade pizza here at Brooklyn Pizzeria. Located in Spring Lake, NC, our pizza shop brings New York City to you! Dine-in with us for a beautiful time with the family or call to place an order for pick up. We also offer limited delivery services. We treat our customers like family and can’t wait to serve you and your family!

We offer delicious, freshly made pizza!

Brooklyn Pizzeria team in Spring Lake, NC
Close-up shot of chef's hands covered in flour making a pizza

Fresh ingredients & handmade pizza since 1992.

Here at Brooklyn Pizzeria, we bake our pizzas from scratch with the freshest mozzarella and homemade sauce made daily. We work hard to provide our customers with top-quality customer service and full stomachs! We make sure you get your bang for your buck with large portions and fresh ingredients. Located in Spring Lake, NC, and delivering to surrounding areas, we ensure that you get hot, delicious pizza and much more!

We treat our customers like family.

“I lived in New Jersey for over 12 years. I had pizza all over. This is the real deal! If you gave these guys a bad rating, go back to your cardboard and ketchup pizza chain. As old as I am, I am sure that I’ve been to over 500 places. These folks make my top five.”


“We have been looking for our go-to pizza place, and now we have found it. This thing was huge, weighed a ton, and tasted perfect like you would expect. Inside was clean, bright, and well sanitized. You have to check it out for yourself!”

Dennis L.

“Excellent service. Clean restaurant. We love that the pizza has a thin crust and fresh ingredients. The staff was very friendly. I highly recommend this business! It’s very affordable for the huge slices of cheese of pepperoni!”

Barbara P.

“Great pizza! I called ahead to eat in every time we went. Seating is limited, but we’ve had no problems eating there. The size of the pizza is awesome. Best of all is the staff- they’re above and beyond great.”

Sherri L.

“This is exactly what the pizza joint I look for. The service is great, the price is more than fair, and the restaurant feels like an early 90s relic. Slices are bigger than your head and taste just like a pop-in pizza spot in Manhattan.”

Mac M.

“Amazingly nostalgic. It tastes like Brooklyn came to North Carolina! Just the right amount of vinegar and oil. This is one of my new favorite places to eat!”

Ceant’e P.

“The pizza is simply the best! Buy it by the slice or a whole pie. Worth every penny!”

Sarah G.

“The best pizza you will find in NC period. This place truly has NY style pizza and makes me miss home a little less whenever I stop by”

Nicky M.

Miss New Yorks pizza? Come to Brooklyn Pizzeria! Taste like back home

Shady R.

“The pizza is good and the employees are friendly. The ravioli was really good. They have garlic knots, too.”

Brian J.

Brooklyn Pizzeria | Spring Lake, NC

Dine with us.

Brooklyn Pizzeria
1125 North Bragg Blvd
Spring Lake, NC, 28390

Monday - Saturday: 11 AM - 9 PM
Sundays: Closed